|
Anti-Semitism Installment Four
I'm continuing my treatise on anti-Semitism,
after a one-newsletter hiatus on the subject.
But first, a few words of apology.
I do my best to answer emails, but sometimes
they get lost before I respond. I am only human,
and my computers aren't much better. And there
are other people in my house who use our
computers (it feels good to have others to
blame). If you didn't get a response, it was
probably not intentional. I am especially sorry
about one email, an intelligent, somber letter
by someone concerned with anti-Semitism. I read
the letter quickly and when I returned a couple
of days later to respond, I went nuts trying to
find it - unsuccessfully.
The writer said that my ideas were overly
simplistic - that there are many people who are
actively looking to hurt Jews. I agree. My views
are simple and, I admit, may even be
over-simplistic. I have mixed feelings about
them even as I write. My parents were both
Holocaust survivors, and I was physically
attacked several times in my youth for being a
Jew. I know well what anti-Semitism is like. But
ultimate truth is simple, and even complexity is
a combination of simple things. Since
anti-Semitism has not nearly disappeared from
the world despite all our efforts, certainly
some of what we have been doing is not working.
When solutions don't work, the common tendency
is to try them even harder, when a completely
different approach may be what's needed. I want
hatred and violence ended as much as anyone, but
I can't see how it is possible to ever solve our
problem without first ridding ourselves of a
victim mentality.
Read Previous Newsletters and Anti-Semitism Installments
|
|
Bullies to Buddies Rule Number Three: Don't Be Afraid |
 |
|
My third rule for turning enemies into friends
is not to be afraid. Fear, by definition, is
felt toward enemies. We don't need to fear
friends because they are not intending to harm
us. When we are afraid of anti-Semites, we are
treating them like enemies. So we can't expect
them to treat us like friends.
When we fear others, we automatically lose. We
put them in the stronger position. When
anti-Semites feel that we fear them, we give
them power over us and we are in the
weaker, losing position. Since all living
creatures are biologically programmed to seek
power and to win conflicts, the very act of
fearing anti-Semites actually encourages them to
keep on doing the things that scare us. And
there is not necessarily any awareness on their
part that we are encouraging them by being
afraid of them. Since we fear them, they cannot
respect us, so there is no motivation on their
part to treat us with respect.
Thirdly, fear is related to hatred. When we fear
others, we usually hate them. Can we expect
to turn anti-Semites into our friends if we hate
them? Of course not! If they feel we hate them,
they will hate us right back.
When we fear people, we avoid them. But the only
good way to reduce racism is by being in contact
with those that hate our group so they can come
to see us as human beings rather than as a
stereotype. By staying away from them, we forego
the chance of getting to know each other as
human beings. We deny ourselves the opportunity
to diminish the stereotypes and hatred.
Jews have often wanted to hide their identity to
avoid discrimination or because they are
embarrassed by being different. (I would be
dishonest to say that I, myself, have been totally
free of this). They have abandoned outward
display of their Jewishness, and often changed
their names to sound less Jewish. Ultimately, I
don't think we can earn respect of the Gentile
world by trying to disguise who we are, and
it certainly does not raise our self-respect. I have
great admiration for those Jews, particularly
the Ultra-Orthodox, who retain their traditional
dress and customs without concern that others
will see them as strange or funny-looking.
When we fear others, we feel like victims, and
victims tend to feel self-righteous. We believe
we are the good ones and they are the bad ones.
Some of the nastiest, most vindictive people I
have come across are people who feel like
self-righteous victims. They think they are
allowed to say or do anything because they are
on the side of right. Thus, we Jews may
sometimes say some pretty hateful things about
those we perceive as hating us, not even
realizing that we are sometimes being meaner to
them than they are to us. We are unaware that
such actions makes us no better than those we are
condemning.
The ultimate road to peace is not "hate your
enemy," but "love your enemy." Unfortunately,
many Jews reject this idea because it is
attributed to Jesus, and we have come to shun
the teachings of Jesus because of the
almost-two-thousand-year history of persecution
of Jews by Christiandom. I was recently
informed by a Jewish scholar that the idea of
"loving your enemy" is also found in Jewish
mysticism. Let us not forget that Jesus was born
a Jew and died a Jew, and his moral teachings
were Jewish teachings. If you think about it,
"love your enemy" is the ultimate expression of
the Golden Rule: since we would want our enemies
to love us (which would stop them from being our
enemies), we have to love them, too. This is the
only chance we have of turning them into friends.
Not all fear is unjustified. People should
rightly fear those who have hurt them in the
past, for the best predictor of future behavior
is past behavior. Millions of Jews have been
killed by those that have hated us over the
millennia and, of course, the possibility of
further atrocities is always there. But we have
to be realistic. Most of the individuals who
have hurt Jews in the past are already dead, and
just because some people today hate Jews, we
needn't treat them like individuals who have harmed
Jews in the past. In most countries today - at
least in the ones where Jewish populations are
found - harming Jews is just as much of a crime
as harming anyone else, and the legal system
protects us, so we don't have to fear
anti-Semites as thought they are about to kill
us. But by fearing them, we are unwittingly
increasing the likelihood that they might want
to do so, for the reasons stated above. Our fear
can become a self-fulfilling prophecy.
I have heard many people criticize Jews as paranoid,
and there is certainly some truth to it. For a
group that has produced a disproportionately
high percentage of mental health professionals,
we should learn to give up this unhealthy
attitude. Most people, especially today in the
democracies of the world, don't hate us as much
as we may think they do. Christian leaders, in
particular, have made great strides in accepting
Jews and denouncing anti-Semitism. Nevertheless,
many of us remain suspicious, and believe that
their new friendliness is only a step towards
their true goal of converting us to
Christianity. The truth is that many of
Christians do, indeed, befriend Jews with
the hope of converting us. This doesn't mean
that they hate us and want to do us harm. From
their perspective, they are doing us a favor by
trying to convert us. If our Jewish identity is
not strong enough to counter Christians'
attempts to convert us, is it their failing, or
ours?
|
| Quick Links... |
 |
|